Newsletter Subscribe
Enter your email address below and subscribe to our newsletter
Is a Short-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgage Right for Me?
Share your love
With mortgage rates still elevated and market uncertainty lingering, many Canadian homeowners and first-time buyers are rethinking the traditional 5-year fixed mortgage. More and more borrowers are choosing short-term fixed-rate options — usually for 1 to 3 years — as a way to ride out the current high-rate environment without locking in long-term.
In this guide, we’ll break down exactly what a short-term fixed-rate mortgage is, how it compares to other mortgage options, and how to know if it’s the right fit for your financial goals.
What Are Short-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgages?
A short-term fixed-rate mortgage has a set interest rate that lasts for a shorter duration — usually 1, 2, or 3 years. Your mortgage payments stay the same during the term, which gives you predictability. At the end of the term, you’ll need to renew or refinance at whatever the rates are at that time.
These mortgages are often seen as a strategic move — a way to “wait out” high interest rates in hopes that better deals will be available when it’s time to renew.
📆 Fixed-Term Mortgage Comparison: 1-Year vs 3-Year vs 5-Year
Choosing a fixed-rate mortgage? Here’s how the popular 1-year, 3-year, and 5-year fixed terms stack up across key factors:
| Feature | 1-Year Fixed | 3-Year Fixed | 5-Year Fixed |
|---|---|---|---|
| 📉 Average Rate (2025 est.) | 5.94% | 5.59% | 5.34% |
| ⏳ Rate Lock Duration | 12 months | 36 months | 60 months |
| 📈 Interest Rate Risk | High (renews quickly) | Medium | Low (stable for longer) |
| 🔓 Flexibility | Good for short-term plans | Balanced option | Best for long-term stability |
| 💸 Penalty if Broken | Usually lower | Moderate | Potentially higher |
📌 Tip: Go short if you expect rates to drop soon. Choose long if you value payment stability or expect rates to rise. 3-year terms offer a smart middle ground in uncertain markets.
Pros and Cons of Short-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgages
Short-term fixed rates offer some distinct advantages — but also come with risks. Whether they’re right for you depends on your financial flexibility and your view on where rates are headed.
Advantages:
- You get payment certainty over the term, without locking in for 5 years
- You may pay a lower penalty if you break your mortgage early
- You’ll be able to renew sooner if rates fall in the near future
Disadvantages:
- You’ll face renewal more often, which can be stressful in a volatile market
- If rates rise even further, you could end up with a higher rate after renewal
- If rates drop during your term, you won’t benefit until you renew
📆 Short vs. Long-Term Fixed Mortgage: Pros & Cons
Deciding between a short-term (1–3 year) or long-term (5+ year) fixed-rate mortgage? Here’s how each option compares on key factors:
| Factor | Short-Term Fixed (1–3 Years) | Long-Term Fixed (5+ Years) |
|---|---|---|
| 💸 Interest Rates | Often slightly higher (short term risk) | Usually lower for longer stability |
| 📈 Rate Risk | Higher – renew sooner in uncertain market | Lower – locked in for 5+ years |
| 🔄 Flexibility | Better if you may sell or refinance soon | Best for long-term stability & budget planning |
| 🔐 Penalty If Broken | Lower | Potentially high IRD penalties |
| 👤 Ideal For | Buyers expecting rate drops or short-term plans | Buyers who want predictable costs and less risk |
📌 Tip: Short terms = more flexibility but more frequent renewals. Long terms = more stability, but potentially higher penalties if your plans change.
Is It Right for You? Key Considerations
Here’s what to think about before choosing a short-term fixed mortgage:
- Your financial goals: Are you planning to sell your home or refinance soon? A short-term mortgage could work well.
- Your risk tolerance: If you don’t like the uncertainty of frequent renewals, you may prefer a longer term.
- Market outlook: If economists and lenders are expecting rates to drop within a couple of years, a short-term fixed lets you avoid locking in high rates for too long.
Many borrowers who took on ultra-low rates in 2020-2021 are now facing renewals at much higher rates. For them, a 1- or 2-year fixed term could help bridge the gap until rates settle.
Short-Term vs Long-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgages
Longer terms (like the traditional 5-year fixed) offer stability and fewer renewals. They’re a great fit if you want to budget with complete certainty and avoid rate volatility. But they often come with higher break penalties, and if rates fall during your term, you’re stuck unless you pay a fee to refinance.
Shorter terms give you more flexibility. If rates improve, you can take advantage sooner. If your life plans change (like moving or upgrading homes), it’s also easier and cheaper to break a short-term mortgage.
📆 1-Year vs 5-Year Fixed: Break Penalties & Renewal Cycles
Fixed-rate mortgages offer security—but breaking your term early can be costly. Here’s how 1-year and 5-year fixed mortgages compare in terms of penalties and renewal timing:
| Feature | 1-Year Fixed | 5-Year Fixed |
|---|---|---|
| 🔁 Renewal Frequency | Every 12 months | Once every 5 years |
| 💥 Early Break Penalty Type | Typically 3 months’ interest | Higher of 3 months’ interest or IRD* |
| 💸 Estimated Penalty (on $400K at 5%) | ~$5,000 | Up to $12,000 (IRD-dependent) |
| 📈 Rate Risk Exposure | High – renews during market changes | Low – protected from volatility |
| 🛠️ Ideal For | Short-term plans or flexibility needs | Long-term stability and predictability |
*IRD = Interest Rate Differential. Penalties vary by lender and current posted rates. Always ask your lender to calculate both options before breaking your term.
How to Qualify for a Short-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgage
The qualification process is the same as any other mortgage. Lenders will review:
- Your income and employment status
- Your credit score
- Your debt ratios
- Your down payment
- Your property’s value
Even if you’re renewing or switching lenders, you may need to requalify. And remember: short-term fixed rates still need to pass the mortgage stress test — so lenders will qualify you based on the higher of 5.25% or your rate + 2%.
Alternatives to Short-Term Fixed-Rate Mortgages
Not sure if short-term fixed is the best fit? You might consider:
- 5-year fixed: Better for risk-averse borrowers who want long-term stability
- Variable rate: Typically lower than fixed rates in a falling rate environment, but comes with payment and interest cost fluctuations
- Adjustable rate: Payment stays static but more of your payment goes toward interest when rates rise
- Blend-and-extend: A strategy offered by some lenders to combine your current rate with a new longer-term rate, letting you renew early
🔄 Compare Fixed, Variable, and Adjustable Rate Mortgages
Use this simple tool to understand how each mortgage type performs under changing interest rates. Try it with your loan amount and see the projected payments!
1 Year
3 Years
5 Years
| Mortgage Type | Interest Rate | Monthly Payment | Risk Profile |
|---|---|---|---|
| 📌 Fixed Rate | 5.24% | $2,989 | Low – rate stays the same |
| 📈 Variable Rate (VRM) | 5.05% | $2,900 | Medium – payment stays, balance changes |
| 🔁 Adjustable Rate (ARM) | 5.05% | $2,925 (varies with rate) | High – payment changes with prime |
📌 Tip: Fixed gives you predictability, variable offers savings if rates fall, and adjustable reacts instantly to rate hikes or drops. Choose based on your budget comfort and risk appetite.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are short-term fixed-rate mortgages cheaper than long-term? Not always — but they could be, depending on the rate outlook. If rates fall, you may save money by renewing sooner at a better rate.
Can I break a short-term mortgage early? Yes, but you’ll pay a penalty — usually 3 months’ interest or the interest rate differential (IRD), whichever is higher.
Can I renew into a longer-term mortgage later? Absolutely. At renewal, you can switch to any term that suits your new goals and market conditions.
Do short-term mortgages make sense in 2025? If you believe rates will decline over the next 1-2 years, short-term fixed lets you secure a predictable payment now and renew into lower rates later.
Final Thoughts
In today’s market, short-term fixed-rate mortgages are a smart option for many Canadians who want a blend of stability and flexibility. They can help you manage your payments today — while keeping the door open for savings tomorrow.
But they’re not for everyone. Always weigh the pros and cons based on your own situation. And when in doubt, talk to a mortgage expert who can run the numbers and help you make the right call.
