Canada’s housing affordability problem has moved from simmering to critical. A recent analysis by the Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) highlights the scale of the challenge: over the next decade, the country must build 3.2 million new homes, or roughly 227,000 units per year, just to stabilize affordability. Even at that level, Canada would still be short by 65,000 homes annually, underscoring how deep the structural gap has become.

This revelation has reignited debate on whether Canada’s current policy framework and market dynamics are remotely adequate to meet the demand for homes—especially in major metros where housing costs already outpace average incomes.

The Roots of the Housing Shortage

Several long-term issues explain how Canada reached this point:

Chronic Underbuilding: Over the last two decades, housing supply has consistently lagged behind population growth. This gap has only widened in recent years, as record immigration combined with limited land supply in urban centers.
Price-to-Income Ratio: In cities like Toronto and Vancouver, the ratio of home prices to household incomes has ballooned to levels well above global averages, leaving even middle-class families priced out.
Rental Market Pressure: With fewer households able to buy, demand has shifted to the rental sector, driving rents higher and increasing affordability concerns for young Canadians.

The result is a housing ecosystem where affordability is deteriorating across ownership and rental markets simultaneously.

Political Responses: Ambitious But Questioned

Prime Minister Mark Carney has floated one of the boldest proposals yet: creating a Build Canada Homes (BCH) entity tasked with delivering 500,000 homes per year. This number goes well beyond the PBO’s projection and would, on paper, bring affordability back within reach.

But skepticism remains. Developers argue that development charges, zoning red tape, and labor shortages make such targets difficult to achieve. Kevin Lee, CEO of the Canadian Home Builders’ Association, has repeatedly flagged high municipal fees as a major barrier, discouraging builders from undertaking large projects despite overwhelming demand.

Some analysts say political promises to “fast build” housing must be backed by practical incentives like tax credits, GST rebates, and federal-provincial alignment on permitting.

Why Affordability Keeps Slipping

The mismatch between housing demand and supply isn’t just a numbers game. It’s also about what types of homes are being built.

Luxury Condos vs. Starter Homes: Developers often prefer high-margin condo towers in urban cores, while the market desperately needs affordable family-sized units, townhomes, and duplexes.
Labor & Materials: Construction costs have risen sharply due to labor shortages and global supply chain issues, further discouraging affordable builds.
Investor Demand: In many regions, speculative buying has kept prices elevated, putting extra strain on buyers relying on mortgages.

These dynamics ensure that even when housing is built, it may not solve affordability in meaningful ways for average Canadians.

Risks of Inaction

If housing supply isn’t ramped up aggressively, several risks loom:

Locked-Out Generation: Younger Canadians may permanently exit the housing market, turning “dreams of ownership” into long-term rental realities.
Economic Strain: Employers in major cities face hiring challenges when workers can’t afford to live near their jobs.
Wider Inequality: Wealth gaps may worsen, as only households with existing real estate see their assets grow while others fall further behind.

The PBO warns that without systemic reform, affordability will deteriorate even further, creating long-term social and economic instability.

Potential Solutions on the Table

Streamlining Permitting: Cutting red tape could shave years off project timelines, bringing homes to market faster.
Public Land Use: Governments could unlock surplus land for affordable housing development, reducing costs.
Incentives for Builders: Rebates, low-interest financing, or subsidies could encourage construction of lower-margin affordable units.
Stronger Rental Policies: Expanding purpose-built rental housing with tax incentives may relieve pressure on renters.

Together, these steps could bridge some of the gap—but execution and coordination across government levels remain critical.

What It Means for Borrowers and Homebuyers

For Canadians navigating the housing market today, the PBO’s findings may feel like confirmation of what they already know: buying a home is harder than ever. Mortgage borrowers are squeezed on both ends—by high interest rates and by scarce supply that inflates prices.

For first-time buyers, it underscores the importance of exploring creative pathways—shared ownership, longer amortizations, or even relocating to more affordable regions. For policymakers, it’s a call to move beyond announcements and into action.

The gap between Canada’s housing supply and its affordability goals is widening, not shrinking. With a shortfall of 3.2 million homes projected through 2035, the path forward requires urgent, coordinated action. Ambitious political promises like BCH may help, but unless regulatory barriers are reduced and incentives restructured, Canada risks deepening its affordability crisis.

For now, Canadians must brace for a market where affordability challenges remain front and center—and where mortgage decisions are as much about survival as they are about ownership dreams.

Need Mortgage Guidance?

Buying or refinancing in today’s market can feel overwhelming. Our experts can help you compare rates, understand your options, and find the right mortgage solution for your needs.

Talk to a Mortgage Expert