AI Tools in Mortgage Decisions — Helpful, But No Match for a Human Broker

AI Is Entering the Mortgage Conversation

From grocery shopping to investment advice, AI is becoming a go-to assistant in everyday life. Now, it’s showing up in one of the most important financial decisions Canadians will ever make: getting a mortgage.

In the U.S., a recent study found that 39% of homebuyers in Q2 2025 used AI tools like ChatGPT or Google’s Gemini to answer mortgage-related questions. People are asking AI to:

• Calculate potential mortgage payments
• Compare fixed vs variable rates
• Explain terms like “amortization” or “GDS/TDS ratio”
• Estimate affordability based on income and down payment

It’s fast, free, and available 24/7—qualities that make it especially appealing to first-time buyers. But while AI can be a great starting point, mortgage professionals warn it’s not a replacement for expert guidance.

---

How Canadian Buyers Are Using AI

Canadian mortgage brokers are seeing a similar trend. Clients are coming to initial meetings already armed with AI-generated numbers and advice—sometimes accurate, sometimes misleading.

For example:

• Payment estimates from AI tools can be close to reality but may ignore lender-specific rules, insurance premiums, or property tax variations.
• Rate comparisons might reflect national averages, not the exclusive rates brokers can secure from niche lenders.
• Down payment advice could overlook provincial first-time buyer programs, such as Ontario’s Land Transfer Tax rebate or B.C.’s First-Time Home Buyers’ Program.

---

Where AI Gets It Right

AI shines in areas like:

• Basic education: Explaining mortgage terms in plain language
• Quick calculations: Offering rough payment and interest comparisons
• Scenario testing: Showing how payments change if rates rise or fall

These functions can help buyers feel more informed before they speak to a lender or broker.

---

Where AI Falls Short

1. Missing the Human Context

AI doesn’t know the emotional and lifestyle factors behind your purchase. A human broker can consider things like your job stability, family plans, and comfort level with debt.

2. Outdated or Generic Data

AI may not pull from real-time rate sheets. Mortgage rates can change daily in Canada, especially in competitive markets.

3. No Access to Lender Exceptions

Brokers often secure approvals for clients with unique income situations (e.g., self-employed, gig workers) by negotiating directly with lenders—something AI can’t do.

4. Lack of Accountability

If AI’s advice leads to a bad decision, there’s no recourse. Licensed brokers are regulated, insured, and bound by professional standards.

---

Canadian Case Study: The Halifax Buyer

In Halifax, Mark—a first-time homebuyer—used AI to figure out what he could afford. The tool estimated he could borrow $450,000 based on his $85,000 salary and $40,000 down payment.

When he met with a broker, he discovered that because of his existing car loan and a slightly higher property tax rate in Halifax, his actual maximum was closer to $420,000. Without that broker intervention, Mark could have wasted time making offers on homes he couldn’t finance.

---

How to Use AI Wisely in Your Mortgage Journey

Start with AI for General Learning

Ask AI to explain terms, payment basics, and rate types. Use it to clarify concepts before meeting a professional.

Double-Check with a Human Expert

Bring your AI findings to a licensed broker. They can validate the numbers and add lender-specific insights.

Use AI for “What If” Scenarios

Test how your payments might change if interest rates go up 1% or if you make a lump sum payment mid-term.

Don’t Rely on AI for Approval Numbers

Only a broker or lender can give you an accurate pre-approval based on your full financial profile.

---

The Broker Advantage Over AI

Access to More Lenders
While AI can list big banks, brokers have access to dozens of lenders, including credit unions and monoline lenders with niche products.

Negotiation Power
Brokers can secure better rates or terms through direct relationships with underwriters—something no AI tool can match.

Local Market Knowledge
AI doesn’t know that one neighborhood in Ottawa has higher condo fees than another or that a certain area in Calgary is in a floodplain affecting insurance costs.

Personalized Strategy
A broker can tailor a mortgage plan that matches your career trajectory, family plans, and investment goals.

AI tools are a welcome addition to the mortgage research toolkit, but they work best as supplements—not substitutes—for professional advice. In a high-stakes decision like homeownership, the blend of AI speed and human expertise offers the best outcome.

If you’re starting your homebuying journey, try AI for learning—but bring the results to a broker for a reality check and a competitive edge.

Talk to a Mortgage Expert