Should You Lock in a Mortgage Rate This September? Experts Weigh In

September 2025 has opened with an unusually volatile mortgage market. Fixed mortgage rates have dipped to their lowest levels in ten months, but the signals from bond yields, central banks, and inflation remain mixed.

For Canadian borrowers—whether they’re renewing, refinancing, or buying for the first time—the question is simple but pressing: Should I lock in my mortgage rate now, or wait in hopes of something better?

Mortgage professionals and analysts are weighing in, and their advice reflects the competing forces driving today’s rates.

---

Why the Question Matters Now

Mortgage rates don’t move in a vacuum. In Canada, they are tied closely to government bond yields, inflation expectations, and Bank of Canada policy. Globally, central banks are treading carefully: the U.S. Federal Reserve is signaling patience, while the Bank of England and European Central Bank have already trimmed rates modestly.

At the same time, Canadian households are stretched thin. According to CMHC data, mortgage carrying costs now eat up more than 60% of disposable income in cities like Toronto and Vancouver. Even a quarter-point change in interest rates can mean hundreds of dollars more or less per month for families.

---

What Experts Are Saying

• Some urge locking in now. Several mortgage brokers note that lenders are offering competitive discounts on fixed terms, particularly 3- and 5-year mortgages. The thinking: with bond yields hovering near multi-month lows, lenders are passing along some of that relief. Locking in could protect borrowers from unexpected market reversals.
• Others see room for further declines. Analysts at large banks suggest that if Canada’s economy continues to soften—echoing the recent GDP contraction—yields could fall further, pushing rates lower. Borrowers who wait may benefit, but the risk is that a rebound in inflation or a hawkish Bank of Canada message could erase those gains.
• Variable vs. fixed remains a big split. Adjustable-rate mortgages, tied directly to the Bank of Canada overnight rate, have stabilized. But with only modest cuts priced in for 2025, they may not offer the relief that many Canadians expect. Fixed mortgages, tied more closely to global bond markets, have seen more movement lately.

---

Case Scenarios for Borrowers

---

The Market Data at a Glance

• Average Canadian 5-Year Fixed Rate (Sept 2025): 5.14% (down from 5.45% in June)
• Average Variable Rate: 6.10% (largely unchanged since July)
• Government of Canada 5-Year Bond Yield: 3.12% (lowest since November 2024)
• Inflation: 2.7% year-over-year, trending closer to Bank of Canada’s 2% target

These figures highlight the delicate balance: a modestly cooling economy that justifies lower rates, but inflation still slightly above target.

---

Why It Matters for Canadian Households

Mortgage affordability remains a national stress point. Even as home prices show signs of stabilization, the cost of borrowing dictates how far a paycheck goes.

A Toronto couple refinancing a $650,000 mortgage could save nearly $200 a month by locking in today’s 5-year fixed rates compared to rates available three months ago. On the flip side, if rates drop another quarter point later this fall, that same couple might save an extra $90 a month—illustrating the gamble in waiting.

---

Expert Takeaway

Mortgage advisors emphasize that there is no one-size-fits-all answer. As Rob Chrisman, a veteran mortgage analyst, noted in his September newsletter: “Borrowers shouldn’t try to outguess the market. A bird in hand often beats the risk of chasing a slightly better deal.”

The practical advice:

• If certainty and peace of mind matter, locking in now is the safer bet.
• If you have financial flexibility and appetite for risk, waiting may reward you—but only if the economy continues to soften.

September 2025 is shaping up to be a pivotal month for mortgage decisions. The choice to lock in or wait isn’t just about numbers—it’s about household stability, risk tolerance, and long-term planning.

---